Intracerebral hemorrhage accounts for 10-20% of all stroke cases. the first 30-days mortality rates approaching 35-52%, only 21% of all patients have the ability to operate independently after six months. Despite of advances in diagnosis and treatment, mortality during hospitalization has decreased only 6% for ten years (1990-2000), whereas cerebral infarction has decreased 36%, subarachnoid hemorrhage has decreased 10%. Deterioration of consciousness and the inability to protect the airway, hypoxemia is common in Intracerebral hemorrhage patients. To maintain respiration play an important role in these patients including the role of mechanical ventilation. Indications for mechanical ventilation must be based on many features including: clinical and paraclinical features. In patients with intracerebral hemorrhage, we want to determine whether there are any features related to indications for mechanical ventilation in order to indicate accurately.
Intracerebral hemorrhagic patients requiring mechanical ventilation has specific features. There are many studies of Intracerebral hemorrhage in general but not many studies of stroke patients requiring mechanical ventilation.
Therefore, we studied the thesis "Studying clinical, paraclinical features and indications for mechanical ventilation in moderate and large supratentorial intracerebral hemorrhage”.
Objectives:
Assess clinical, paraclinical features in patients with moderate and large supratentorial itracerebral hemorrhage requiring mechanical ventilation.
Determine some features related to indications for mechanical ventilation in patients with moderate and large supratentorial itracerebral hemorrhage requiring mechanical ventilation.
THE NEW CONTRIBUTION OF THE THESIS
Assess clinical and paraclinical features in patients with moderate and large supratentorial itracerebral hemorrhage requiring mechanical ventilation in order to provide experienced michanical ventilation in stroke patients for doctors.
Determine features related to indications for mechanical ventilation in patients with moderate and large supratentorial itracerebral hemorrhage requiring mechanical ventilation. These features should be considered to indicate mechanical ventilation in Intracerebral hemorrhagic patients.
THE STRUCTURE OF THE THESIS
The reseach consists of 124 pages: 2 pages of introduction, 35 page of overview, 16 pages of subjects and methods, 31 pages of research results, 37 pages of discussion, 2 pages of conclusions and 1 page of suggesion.
The reserch consist of 119 references, including 52 Vietnamese documents and materials in English 67
Chapter 1 - OVERVIEW
Consequences of increased intracranial pressure in patients with acute intracerebral hemorrhage
According to the formula:
Cerebral perfusion pressure = Mean blood pressure - Intracranial pressure.
Increased intracranial pressure can lead to brain ischemia because of decreased cerebral perfusion pressure. In addition, increased intracranial pressure can cause brain herniation.
The role of CO2 in the management of increased intracranial pressure
CO2 plays a role in the regulation of cerebral blood flow: Increased CO2 is due to cerebral vasodilation and increased cerebral blood flow. In contrast, reduction of CO2 lead to vasoconstriction and reduction of cerebral blood flow; therefore, intracranial pressure is reduced.
Mechanical ventilation not only maintain the arterial blood oxygen saturation, but also control increased intracranial pressure by adjusting the arterial PCO2.
Indications for mechanical ventilation in stroke patients.
In general, indications for mechanical ventilation in stroke patients have been controlversial.
According to David L. McDonagh and Cecil O. Borel
Deterioration of consciousness (Glasgow < 10 )
Injured brain affects the ability to control respiration
Posterior fossa lesions due to the inability of protect the airway
Respiratory failure in patients with Guillain – Barres, Myasthemia gravis...
Pulmonary complications: aspiration pneumonitis, atelectasis..
According to Rahul Nanchal and Ahmed J. Khan
Acute injured brain due to loss of airway protective reflexes.
Acute respiratory failure: Septic shock, neuromuscular diseases, ARDS...
In anticipation of the clinical worsening, threatening respiratory failure, inability to protect the airway.
Acording to Eelco F.M. Wijdicks
Acute injured brain due to loss of airway protective reflexes.
Acute neuromuscular respiratory failure: hội chứng Guillain-Barré syndrome, Myasthemia gravis...
Respiratory failure in patients with previous lung desease such as: acute pulmonary edema, aspiration pneumonitis.
Acording to Ellen Deibert and Michael N. Diringer.
Coma (Glasgow coma scale ≤ 8).
Inability to clean throat, phlegm widely.
Loss of cough reflex, vomitive reflex.
Airway obtruction due to paralysis of the muscles in the throat.
Acute respiratory failure.
In summary, deterioration of consciousness (Glasgow coma scale ≤ 8), acute respiratory failure and inability to protect the airway are the main base for intubation. In fact, clinical features cause respiratory failure may be considered to intubate, especially early decision before coma and respiratory failure appear.
According to Hoang Khanh, studying prognostic factors in stroke ischemic patients confirmed the volume of infaction correlated very closely with Glasgow coma scale. Nguyen Van Thong at al also found that the hematoma volume correlated very closely with Glasgow coma scale and respiratory disorders. Therefore, hematoma and infaction volume also could be a factor for deciding to intubate ... This issue needs to be studied further.
Chapter 2 - SUBJECTS AND METHODS
2.1. Studying subjects
Patients with acute moderate and large supratentorial itracerebral hemorrhage (first 72 hours), divided into two groups, the group of patients with mechanical ventilation and the others without mechanical ventilation. The studying Patients were inpatients of the Stroke center - Central Military Hospital 108 from january 2008 to March 2012.
Selection criteria for study patients
Including patients with acute moderate and large supratentorial itracerebral hemorrhage: Confirmed diagnosis based on the definition of intracerebral hemorrhage of the World Health Organization (1989). Intracerebral hemorhage was diagnosed by computed tomography scan of brain. The hematoma located above the tentorium. Hematoma volume was calculated by the formula of Broderick: hematoma volume is moderate from 30 to 60 cm3, large over 60 cm3, arrive at the hospital before 72 hours from the onset.
Exclusion criteria:
Exclusion criteria: Intracerebral hemorrhage due to traumatic brain injury, bleeding in the cerebral infarction, bleeding in cerebral tumor, subarachnoid hemorrhage, intracerebral hemorrhagic patients with severe deseases such as liver failure, renal failure, coagulation disorders...
2.2. Reseach methodology
Study Design
A prospective, observational, follow-up study.
Sample size is determined by formula:
p: estimated ratio, the rate of hemorrhage patients requiring mechanical ventilation estimates 20%. ε: relative error. Z 1-α/22 = 1,96, p = 0.2, ε = 20%, we have n = 196.
In our study, the number of study patients was 230 patients.
Research Contents: All study patients were followed up within 30 days from hospital arrival. The patients were divided into two groups: the group with mechanical ventilation and the others without mechanical ventilation. Indications for mechanical ventilation when at least including one of the following criteria: The Glasgow coma score ≤ 8, acute respiratory failure, loss of protective airway reflexes.
Study the clinical and paraclinical characteristics: the statistical clinical and paraclinical characteristics were compared between the two groups: the group with mechanical ventilation and the others without mechanical ventilation to highlight special clinical and paraclinical characteristics of the group of patients with mechanical ventilation. Study the relative factors to indications for mechanical ventilation: a comparison between two groups: the group with mechanical ventilation and the others without mechanical ventilation. Univariate analysis and multivariate logistic regresion analyses were performed to determine relative factors to indications for mechanical ventilation.
2.3. Data analysis
The results were processed by statistical software SPSS 18.0. Comparison by Chi-square test for categorical variables and t-test for quantitative variables. The difference is statistically significant if p < 0.05.
2.4. Diagram Research
Chapter 3 - FINDINGS
3.1. Clinical faetures
3.1.1. Clinical symptoms
Table 3.9. Neurologic symptoms at hospital arrival
Neurologic symptoms at admission
|
Mechanical ventilation (n=134) (n (%))
|
Non-Mechanical ventilation (n=96) (n(%))
|
Sum
(n=230)
(n (%))
|
p
|
GCS score
|
3-8
|
74 (55,22)
|
0
|
74 (55,22)
|
< 0,05
|
9-12
|
57 (42,53)
|
51 (53,12)
|
108 (46,95)
|
< 0,05
|
13-15
|
3 (2,23)
|
45 (46,87)
|
48 (20,86)
|
< 0,05
|
Central VII palsy
|
122 (91,04)
|
81 (84,37)
|
203 (88,26)
|
< 0,05
|
Meningeal signs
|
66 (49,25)
|
7 (7,29)
|
73 (31,73)
|
< 0,05
|
Bowel, urinary incontinence
|
130 (97,01)
|
50 (52,08)
|
180 (78,26)
|
< 0,05
|
Head-eye deviation
|
80 (59,70)
|
10 (10,41)
|
90 (39,13)
|
< 0,05
|
Absence of pupillary light reflex one or two sides
|
40 (29,85)
|
7 (7,29)
|
47 (20,43)
|
< 0,05
|
Comment: In the group of mechanical ventilation: Severe deteriration of oconsciousness (55,22%), moderate deteriration of oconsciousness (42,53%), meningeal signs (49.25%), Head-eye deviation (59.70%), absence of pupillary light reflex one or two sides (29.85%).
3.1.2. Assessment and prognosis according to the neurologic scale.
Table 3.10. Strength of hand according to the scale of Henry
Henry
score
|
Mechanical ventilation
(n=134)
|
Non- Mechanical ventilation (n=96)
|
Sum
(n=230)
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
0
|
104
|
77,61
|
44
|
45,83
|
148
|
64,35
|
1
|
14
|
10,45
|
16
|
16,66
|
30
|
13,04
|
2
|
10
|
7,46
|
10
|
10,41
|
20
|
8,69
|
3
|
3
|
2,23
|
15
|
15,62
|
18
|
7,82
|
4
|
1
|
0,75
|
6
|
6,25
|
7
|
3,04
|
5
|
2
|
1,49
|
5
|
5,20
|
7
|
3,04
|
P
|
p < 0,05
|
|
Comment: In the group of mechanical ventilation: Strength of hand 0 points (77,6%), non- mechanical ventilation (45,8%).
Bảng 3.12. ICH score
ICH score
|
Mechanical ventilation
(n=134)
|
Non-Mechanical
ventilation (n=96)
|
Sum
(n=230)
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
1
|
3
|
2,23
|
33
|
34,37
|
36
|
15,65
|
2
|
35
|
26,11
|
48
|
50,00
|
83
|
36,08
|
3
|
77
|
57,46
|
14
|
15,58
|
91
|
39,56
|
4
|
15
|
11,19
|
1
|
1,04
|
16
|
6,95
|
5
|
4
|
2,98
|
0
|
0
|
4
|
1,73
|
6
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
P
|
p < 0,001
|
|
Comment: In the group of mechanical ventilation, ICH score was 3 and 4 mainly (57,46% and 11,19%). The group of non-mechanical ventilation was 1 and 2 mainly (34,37% and 50,00%).
Bảng 3.14. Average NIHSS at admission
Groups
|
Average NIHSS
|
P
|
Mechanical ventilation (n=134)
|
22,54 ± 5,91
|
< 0,001
|
Non-Mechanical ventilation (n=96)
|
15,08 ± 4,87
|
Sum (n=230)
|
19,43 ± 6,62
|
|
Comment: Average NIHSS in the group of mechanical ventilation 22,54 ± 5,91 was more than in group of non-mechanical ventilation (15,08 ± 4,87).
3.1.3. Outcome
Table 3.15. 30-day outcome
30-day outcome
|
Mechanical
ventilation (n=134)
|
Non-Mechanical
ventilation (n=96)
|
Sum
(n=230)
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
Good outcome
(Rankin 0-3 )
|
3
|
2,24
|
69
|
71,87
|
72
|
31,30
|
Poor outcome
(Rankin 4-5 )
|
68
|
50,74
|
27
|
28,13
|
95
|
41,30
|
Death
(Rankin 6 )
|
63
|
47,01
|
0
|
0
|
63
|
27,39
|
Comment: In the group of mechanical ventilation, good outcome account for only 2,24 %, mostly poor outcome (50,74 %) and mortality account for 47,01 %.
Table 3.16. Duration from onset to death
Number of pts
(n=63)
|
Duration from onset to death (t)
|
t ≤ 24 giờ
|
24 < t ≤ 48 giờ
|
48< t ≤ 72giờ
|
t > 72giờ
|
Number of pts
|
14
|
12
|
12
|
25
|
Percentage (%)
|
22,22
|
19,04
|
19,05
|
39,68
|
Comment: Most the patients died within the first 72 hours (60.32%). In which, the mortality in the first 24 hours was highest (22.2%).
3.2. Subclinical features
Table 3.20. Serum glucose
Groups
|
Increased serum glucose at admission
|
History of
diabetes
|
≥ 7 mmol/l
|
≥ 11mmol/l
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
Number of pts
|
Percentage %
|
Mechanical ventilation
(n=134)
|
86
|
64,17
|
23
|
17,04
|
8
|
5,97
|
Non-Mechanical
ventilation (n=96)
|
34
|
35,41
|
4
|
4,16
|
6
|
6,25
|
Sum (n=230)
|
120
|
52,17
|
27
|
11,74
|
14
|
6,08
|
P
|
< 0,05
|
< 0,05
|
> 0,05
|
Comment: Percentage of patients with serum glucose ≥ 7 mmol/L and ≥ 11 mmol/L were quite high (64.17% and 17.04%) in the group of mechanical ventilation.
Table 3.22. Serum ion
Groups
|
Disorders of serum sodium, potassium
|
sodium
|
potassium
|
Increase
(n (%))
|
decrease
(n (%))
|
Increase
(n (%))
|
decrease
(n (%))
|
Mechanical ventilation
(n=134)
|
5 (3,73)
|
38 (28,35)
|
3 (2,23)
|
76 (56,71)
|
Non-Mechanical
ventilation (n=96)
|
1 (1,04)
|
34 (35,41)
|
1 (1,04)
|
38 (39,58)
|
Sum (n=230)
|
6 (2,60)
|
72 (31,30)
|
4 (1,73)
|
114 (49,56)
|
p
|
|
> 0,05
|
|
< 0,05
|
Comment: In both groups, the most common disorders of serum sodium and postassium was hyponatremia (31.30%) and hypokalemia (49.56%).
Table 3.23. Hematoma features
Hematoma features
|
Mechanical ventilation
(n=134)
|
Non-Mechanical
ventilation (n=96)
|
Sum
(n=230)
|
p
|
Volume of hematoma
|
30-60cm3
|
78 (58,20)
|
81 (84,37)
|
159 (69,13)
|
< 0,001
|
> 60cm3
|
56 (41,80)
|
15 (15,62)
|
71 (30,86)
|
Mean
|
67,7 ± 46
|
46,6 ± 15
|
58,04 ± 38
|
Midline Shift
|
Grade I
|
28 (20,89)
|
45 (46,87)
|
73 (31,73)
|
< 0,001
|
Grade II
|
51 (38,06)
|
22 (23,92)
|
73 (31,73)
|
Grade III
|
47 (35,07)
|
3 (3,12)
|
50 (21,730
|
Intraventricular hemorrhage
|
84 (62,68)
|
16 (16,66)
|
100 (43,47)
|
< 0,001
|
Blood in subarachnoid space
|
47 (35,07)
|
2 (2,08)
|
49 (21,30)
|
< 0,001
|
Location in the lobes
|
34 (25,37)
|
43 (44,79)
|
77 (33,47)
|
< 0,05
|
Deep location
|
100 (74,63)
|
53 (55,21)
|
153 (66,52)
|
< 0,05
|
Location in more than one lobe
|
15 (11,19)
|
12 (12,50)
|
27 (11,73)
|
> 0,05
|
Comment: Hematoma volume above 60cm3, midline shift grade III and Blood in subarachnoid space account for 41,80 %, 35,82% and 35,07%) in the group of mechanical ventilation.
3.3. Some characteristics related to mechanical ventilation
Table 3.24. Indications for mechanical ventilation
Causes of mechanical ventilation
|
Number of pts
(n= 134)
|
Percentage
(%)
|
Coma (Glasgow ≤ 8)
|
90
|
67,16
|
Acute repiratory failure
|
19
|
14,18
|
inability to protect the airway
|
25
|
18,65
|
Comment: Mechanical ventilation was instituted with coma (67.16%), inability to protect the airway (18.65%) and acute respiratory failure (14.18%).
Table 3.26. Duration of mechanical ventilation and from intubation to tracheostomy
Time of mechanical ventilation, tracheostomy
|
Average number of days
|
Minimum number of days
|
Maximum number of days
|
Mean duration of MV
|
5,1±3,1
|
1
|
17
|
Mean duration from intubation to tracheostomy
|
4,6±1,5
|
3
|
10
|
Comment: The mean duration of mechanical ventilation was 5,1 ± 3,1 days, and mean duration from intubation to tracheostomy was 4,6 ±1,5 days.
Table 3.27. Characteristics arterial blood gases before and during mechanical ventilation
Factors
|
Before mechanical ventilation
|
During mechanical ventilation
|
pH
|
7,42 ± 0,06
|
7,44 ± 0,07
|
PaO2 (mmHg)
|
81,56 ± 11,87
|
119 ± 23,81
|
PaCO2 (mmHg)
|
37,17 ± 5,14
|
33,72 ± 7,16
|
HCO3- (mmol)
|
23,66 ± 2,76
|
22,93 ± 3,74
|
Comment: Arterial oxygen pressure during ventilation (119 ± 23.81 mmHg) was better than before mechanical ventilation (81.56 ± 11.87 mmHg).
Table 3.28. Characteristics arterial blood gases before mechanical ventilation in patients with coma (Glasgow ≤ 8 điểm).
Factors
|
Number of pts (n = 90)
|
Percentage (%)
|
pH
|
< 7,35
|
4
|
4,44
|
≥ 7,35
|
86
|
95,56
|
PaO2 (mmHg)
|
< 60
|
4
|
4,44
|
≥ 60
|
86
|
95,56
|
PaCO2 (mmHg)
|
> 50
|
3
|
3,33
|
≤ 50
|
87
|
96,67
|
Comment: Blood gas tests in patients with coma (Glasgow score ≤ 8): PaO2 ≥ 60 mmHg (95.56%), PaCO2 ≤ 50 mmHg (96.67%), pH ≥ 7.35 (95.56%).
Table 3.29. Withdrawing and weaning from mechanical ventilation
Withdrawing and weaning from mechanical ventilation
|
Number of pts
(n = 71)
|
Percentage (%)
|
Success
|
64
|
90,14
|
Unsuccess
|
7
|
9,86
|
Comment: There were 63 patients died during mechanical ventilation. Withdrawing and weaning from mechanical ventilation success in 71 patients (90.14%)
Table 3.30. Withdrawing endotracheal tube
Withdrawing endotracheal tube
|
Number of pts
(n = 71)
|
Percentage (%)
|
Success
|
30
|
42,25
|
Resetting or tracheostomy
|
41
|
57,75
|
Comment: withdrawal of Endotracheal tube account for only 42.25%.
Table 3.32. Complications related to mechanical ventilation
Complications related to mechanical ventilation.
|
Number of pts
(n = 134)
|
Percentage (%)
|
Pneumonia
|
9
|
6,71
|
Respiratory alkalosis (pH > 7,5)
|
31
|
23,13
|
Endotracheal tube obstruction
|
5
|
3,73
|
Falling endotracheal tube
|
4
|
2,98
|
Hypotention
|
11
|
8,20
|
Comment: The common complication when mechanical ventilation were respiratory alkalosis (23.13%), hypotension (8.20%) pneumonia (6.71%).
3.3. The relative factors to indications for mechanical ventilation
Table 3.34. The clinical factors
Clinical factors
|
Mechanical ventilation
(n=134)
|
Non-Mechanical
ventilation (n=96)
|
p
|
Heart rate >90 beats/minute
(n (%))
|
75 (55,97)
|
26 (27,08)
|
> 0,05
|
Temperature > 37,50C
(n (%))
|
37 (27,61)
|
17 (17,70)
|
> 0,05
|
Diastolic blood pressure
(mmHg)
|
159,5±28,9
|
153±22,9
|
> 0,05
|
Systolic blood pressure (mmHg)
|
93,6±16,4
|
89,2±14,3
|
> 0,05
|
Mean blood pressure (mmHg)
|
110,5±15,6
|
115,6±18,9
|
> 0,05
|
Meningeal signs (n (%))
|
66 (49,25)
|
7 (7,29)
|
< 0,001
|
Head-eye deviation (n (%))
|
80 (59,70)
|
10 (10,41)
|
< 0,001
|
Absence of pupillary light reflex in one or two sides
(n (%))
|
40 (29,85)
|
7 (7,29)
|
< 0,001
|
ICH Score ≥ 3
|
96 (71,64)
|
15 (15,56)
|
< 0,05
|
NIHSS > 20
|
82 (6,12)
|
25 (2,60)
|
< 0,05
|
Comment: The differences between the two groups were significant for meningeal signs, Head-eye deviation, Absence of pupillary light reflex in one or two sides, ICH Score ≥ 3 and NIHSS > 20 (p <0.05).
Table 3.35. Laboratory biochemistry and hematology
Laboratory biochemistry and hematology
|
Mechanical ventilation
(n=134)
|
Non-Mechanical
ventilation (n=96)
|
P
|
Increased leucocyte (n (%))
|
96 (71,64)
|
56 (58,33)
|
> 0.05
|
Increased neutrocyte (n(%))
|
112 (83,58)
|
66 (68,75)
|
> 0.05
|
Leucocyte (G/l)
|
13,2±4,6
|
10,8±3,6
|
> 0,05
|
Erythrocyte (T/l)
|
4,8±1,9
|
4,6±0,67
|
> 0.05
|
Decreased erythrocyte (n (%))
|
31 (23,13)
|
22 (22,91)
|
> 0.05
|
Decreased hemoglobin (n(%))
|
43(32,08)
|
33(34,37)
|
> 0.05
|
Decreased platelet (n (%))
|
11 (8,20)
|
7 (7,29)
|
> 0.05
|
Serum glucose ≥ 11mmol/l
|
23 (17,16)
|
4 (4,16)
|
< 0,05
|
Hypokalemia (n (%))
|
76 (56,71)
|
38 (39,58)
|
< 0.05
|
Hyponatremia (n (%))
|
38 (28,36)
|
34 (35,41)
|
> 0.05
|
Increased serum urea (n (%))
|
16 (11,9)
|
9 (9,37)
|
> 0.05
|
Increased serum creatinine (n (%))
|
28 (20,89)
|
7 (7,29)
|
> 0.05
|
Comment: Among the above factors, the differences between the two groups were significant only for hyperglycemia and Hypokalemia (p < 0,05).
Table 3.36. The characteristics hematoma on computer tomography images of the brain
Factors
|
Mechanical ventilation
(n=134)
|
Non-Mechanical
ventilation (n=96)
|
p
|
Hematoma volume > 60cm3
(n (%))
|
56 (41,79)
|
15 (15,62)
|
< 0.001
|
Midline shift ≥ 1cm
(n (%))
|
47 (35,07)
|
3 (3,12)
|
< 0.001
|
Intraventricular blood (n (%))
|
84 (62,68)
|
16 (16,67)
|
< 0.001
|
Blood in subarachnoid space
(n (%))
|
47 (35,07)
|
2 (2,08)
|
< 0.001
|
Hematoma above 1 lobe (n (%))
|
15 (11,19)
|
12 (12,50)
|
> 0,05
|
Comment: The differences between the two groups were significant for Hematoma volume > 60cm3, Midline shift ≥ 1cm, Intraventricular blood, Blood in subarachnoid space (p < 0,001).
Table 3.37. Multivariate logistic regresion analyses
Factors
|
Odds ratio
|
Confidence interval 95%
|
p
|
History of hypertension
|
2,12
|
0,93 – 4,83
|
> 0,05
|
Meningeal sight
|
3,60
|
0,89 – 14,41
|
> 0,05
|
ICH score ≥ 3
|
0,63
|
0,12 – 3,5
|
> 0,05
|
NIHSS > 20
|
2,02
|
0,92 – 4,40
|
> 0,05
|
Serum Glucose ≥ 11 mmol/l
|
3,61
|
0,86 – 15,06
|
> 0,05
|
Hypokalemia
|
1,7
|
0,86 – 3,73
|
> 0,05
|
Blood in subarachnoid space
|
3,07
|
0,48 – 19,43
|
> 0,05
|
Intraventricular blood
|
0.98
|
0,27 – 3,5
|
> 0,05
|
Head - eye deviation
|
5,11
|
1,64 – 15,96
|
< 0,05
|
Absence of pupillary light reflex in one or two sides
|
3,61
|
1,13 – 11,41
|
< 0,05
|
Hematoma volume > 60 cm3
|
3,14
|
1,28 – 7,68
|
< 0,05
|
Midline shift ≥ 1cm
|
4,80
|
1,32 – 17,35
|
< 0,05
|
Comment: The differences between the two groups were statistically significant for absence of pupillary light reflex in one or two sides, head - eye deviation, hematoma volume > 60cm3, midline shift ≥ 1cm in the multivariate logistic regresion analyses.
AUC = 0,68
Chart 3.5: ROC curve of hematoma volume
Comment: The area under the curve (AUC) of ROC curve of the hematoma volume was 0.68, so it is a prognostic factor for indicated mechanical ventilation.
AUC = 0,82
Chart 3.6: ROC curve of midline shift
Comment: The area under the curve (AUC) of ROC curve of the midline shift was 0.82, so it is a prognostic factor for indicated mechanical ventilation.
Chapter 4 - DISCUSSION
4.1. Clinical features
Clinical symtoms:
Deterioration of oconsciousness in the group of mechanical ventilation: Glasgow coma score ≤ 8 (55,22%), Glasgow coma score 9-12 (42.53%), Glasgow coma score 13-15 (2.23%). Numbers of patients with GCS ≤ 8 was higher than in the other studies. According to Nguyen Minh Hien The proportion of patients with a Glasgow coma score (GCS) 3-5 was 6.3%, GCS 6-9 was 26.5%, GCS 10-14 was 39.1%, consciousness was 26.6%. Claude J. Hemphill III found that the proportion of patients with GCS 3-5 was 22%, GCS 5-12 was 30%, GCS 13-15 was 47%.
Assessment of muscle strength by Henry scale: In the mechanical ventilation group, 0 point of muscle strength hand account for 77.61%, whereas in non-mechanical ventilation group, it account for only 45.83%. It is reasonable because the patient requing mechanical ventilation with large hematoma or at strategic locations, not only affects respiratory function but also affects motor function.
Assessment of severity by intracranial hemorrhagic score (ICH score): In the group of mechanical ventilation, 3 and 4 ICH score account for mainly (57.46% and 11.19%). In the group of non-mechanical ventilation, 1 and 2 ICH score account for mainly (34.37% and 50.00%). The differences between the two groups were statistically significant for ICH score (P <0.001). As we know, the ICH score was a worse prognostic factor, the higher the score the more severe the disease. According to Hempill JC et al, the first 30-days mortality in intracranial hemorrhagic patients with 1,2,3,4 and 5 ICH score were respective 13%, 26%, 72%, 97% and 100%.
Assessment of severity by NIHSS: Mean NIHSS score at admission in mechanical ventilation group was 22.54 ± 5.91 points, in the others group was 15.08 ± 4.87 points. Similar to ICH score, NIHSS scale has prognostic value, the higher NIHSS score the more severe the disease and the ability of patients requiring mechanical ventilation is higher.
The 30-days mortality in patients requiring mechanical ventilation in our study was 47%. According to Tran Thanh Hung and Vu Anh Nhi, the mortality of stroke patients requiring mechanical ventilation was 63.7%. Thorsten Steiner at al studied 124 stroke patients requiring mechanical ventilation, the mortality is 52%. Bushnell at al studied 131 stroke patients underwent mechanical ventilation, the 30-days mortality was 51%.
Assessment of rehabilitation by Modified Rankin scale: In the group of mechanical ventilation, modified Rankin score 5 and 6 points were in most cases (71.63%). The group of non-mechanical ventilation, 3 and 4 modified Rankin score are mainly (88.54%). Thus, patients requiring mechanical ventilation had poor outcome, high mortality.
Chia sẻ với bạn bè của bạn: |