Fraud
•
As
has been repeatedly stated, documentary credits are not
foolproof. There are layers of protection for both the buyer
and the seller, but opportunities for fraud do exist.
•
Many of the opportunities for fraud center around the fact
that banks deal in documents and not goods, and therefore
the seller has the opportunity
for presenting fraudulent
documents.
•
The seller will have difficulty doing this more than once or
twice as no bank will repeatedly accept documents from a
supplier accused of such practices.
16
Fraud
•
The situations listed below are extremely uncommon, but
do exist.
1. Sellers have reported receiving an advice or a confirmation
of a documentary credit from nonexisting banks. The
perpetrator of the fraud attempts to get the seller to ship
goods and present documents for payment to a bank that
does not exist. By the time the seller is aware of the fraud,
the "
buyer
" has received the goods.
2. Buyers have reported receiving empty crates or crates filled
with sand instead of the merchandise they ordered. By the
time they received the shipment
the banks had already
paid the "supplier."
18
Fraud
3. Buyers have reported receiving defective merchandise from
sellers. While there may be some latitude for interpretation of
what constitutes "defective," it is
clear that some suppliers
have purposefully shipped incorrect or substandard goods.
4. Buyers have reported being short-shipped. In some cases
buyers have ordered a valuable commodity sold by weight
and were shortchanged by being charged for the gross weight
rather than the net weight. They were charged the
commodity price per kilogram for the packing materials.
5.
Buyers of commodities, especially gray market goods, have
reported being defrauded by the seller's providing fraudulent
shipping documents, evidencing shipment on a nonexistent
ship.
19