Seameo regional language centre



tải về 421.94 Kb.
Chế độ xem pdf
trang16/33
Chuyển đổi dữ liệu11.05.2022
Kích421.94 Kb.
#51822
1   ...   12   13   14   15   16   17   18   19   ...   33
Textbook evaluation The case of English

spiral ramp
that was raised as the 
construction proceeded. A second theory suggests that the blocks were lifted and placed using 
thousands of huge weight arms’ 
(ibid: 179).
In order to enable students to guess these words, the exercise therefore should have 
incorporated more contextual clues. 
In Example 2, students are not encouraged to go back to the text, locate the instances 
of the words and try to understand their meaning. On the contrary, they are only 


27
asked to translate the words; thus they might just look the words up in a dictionary 
for convenience.
Table 6 also shows that important micro-skills such as making inferences, 
understanding references, understanding discourse markers, understanding text 
organization, recognizing author’s purposes and attitudes, and summarizing are rather 
under-represented in the books. For example, making inferences is dealt with in only 
12 out of 257 activities, understanding references in three activities, understanding 
text organization in one activity, recognizing author’s purposes and attitudes in two 
activities and understanding discourse markers, though spelled out in the syllabus, is 
not catered to at all. Summarizing skills are most often practiced at the post-stage. 
The chance to practice these skills occurs only once in the while-stage.
Indeed, a close examination of the comprehension questions shows that most of 
them are rather ‘straightforward’ and factual in nature, therefore requiring just literal 
or surface understanding of the text. As a result, in extreme cases, many can be 
answered by coping out the sentences in the text without any real language 
reproduction. Very few questions actually require processing of the text at a deeper 
level, for example, bringing different pieces of information together to give a 
complete answer (i.e. summarizing), or reading between the lines (inferring, 
understanding author’s attitudes and so on). This poses a serious limitation because 
real world reading involves more than just literal understanding of factual, 
straightforward information (Cunningsworth 1995).


28
Table 6: Micro-skills developed through while-reading exercises and tasks

tải về 421.94 Kb.

Chia sẻ với bạn bè của bạn:
1   ...   12   13   14   15   16   17   18   19   ...   33




Cơ sở dữ liệu được bảo vệ bởi bản quyền ©hocday.com 2024
được sử dụng cho việc quản lý

    Quê hương